Risk Factors for Stress Fractures and Shin Splints – not what you think.

Last month, a study was published which followed 230 high school runners. Over a 3 year period, almost half of them (102) developed shin splints bad enough to take them out of running for at least one week. In addition, about 10% of them (21) developed stress fractures in their shins.

I treat many high school kids in the clinic with shin splints, and the overwhelming home remedy that they have tried is over the counter orthotics. They are repeatedly told that they are “overpronating”, they have “flat feet” or their “arches are collapsing” and that is the cause of their shin problems.
Is everyone with these injuries overpronating? What do the studies say?

The study mentioned above looked at many factors at the beginning of the study and then followed the runners for 3 years. One of the factors was called “navicular drop” (the navicular bone is a bone in the foot which near the height of the inside arch of the foot. As you run/walk, the foot is supposed to deform and the arch lower a bit. Measuring the amount of “drop” in the navicular will indicate how much the arch deforms) The results of this study showed that navicular drop was in fact, NOT associated with a higher risk of shin splints or stress fractures.

Other studies have shown the same thing: Like this study here. However, other studies show that the amount of navicular drop test DOES correlate: Such as this study here or this study here

So, confusion exists on whether the arch deformation contributes to shin problems . Some studies say “yes”, some say “no”, however, if we step back and look at these studies, were they done on patients who are actually running? Most of the time the answer is “no”. However, we know from previous studies that the static (non-moving) arch height has virtually no correlation to the arch height when running.

So far, all I’ve shown is that there is basically non-agreement on pronation and arch height deformation with shin problems. However, even if we were to “pretend” that it did, what would be the solution? More often than not, the answer is to put the runner in arch molds/footbeds/orthotics. Is that the answer? Not according to this study found here. In fact, that study found that there was actually an INCREASED risk of shin splints in those runners who used orthotics. Yet, another study showed that orthotics provided relief for people with shin splints.

So, there is little to no consensus on whether or not floppy, loose, overpronating feet correlate to shin splints and tibial stress fractures. There is also little consensus on whether or not orthotics help. There are other factors though. Two examples (not a complete list):
1) Impact loading rate. This has been shown to correlate well to stress fractures. Impact loading rate can be modifiable through changes like cadence, where your foot hits the ground, knee excursion etc.
2) Training errors (too much, too soon, too fast). Training errors have been reported to account for as much as 60% of all running injuries.

The only fact is that there is not “ONE” factor associated with these injuries. One has to take a look at the individual’s training and biomechanics and navigate through the maze of information. Maybe it’s time for an appointment with Running Reform?

2 Comments so far:

  1. […] Interesting study on risk factors for shin splints and stress fractures.  While everyone I know has had shin […]

  2. Andre says:

    Hello, My story is the same as so many others you have heard. To be as breif as I can, I am 48 and have been rinung for about 4 years on and off, mostly 3-4 mile 4-5 days a week. Last year I became more serious and ran 2 -1/2 marathons as well as completed the 9 races in NYC to qualify for the marathon in 09. As luck would have it, I was also excepted in 08’s marathon. I began training and by mid july last year I was diagnosed with a stress fracture(after being told it was only a shin splint). I was up to 18 miles at that time and the pain grew so that I could not proceed. I took off a few months, and did not do the 08 marathon. Now it is 09, I saw a specialist and I was dianosed with a soft arch bought very expensive orthodics and began to slowly train. Around my 10 mile long run, the same pain reoccured in the same spot on the same leg. I went back to the Doc, and he gave me an injection to relieve the inflamation and made a minor adjustment to my orthodics. I believe it is broke again by the feel, but not sure I really want a 3rd bone scan or MRI in 18 months to prove it. Can I cross train with a bike, and wear a brace so I can contnue to run this fall? I think iif I cross train, and only run 18 once, then 20 once I should be able to do 26. Please help

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>